:format(webp)/cdn.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_image/image/31201593/482441541.0.jpg)
Review has upheld 60% of calls (21 of 35) through Saturday night. Umpires at third base have fared the worst thus far: going 1-3 (33%), those at second have gone 4-9 (44%), and 9-16 first base calls have been upheld (56%). Home plate umpires have yet to be wrong (to some debate)—perfect at 7-7.
| Date | Review | Umpire | Name | Club | Call | Result | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5-Apr | 35 | 1B | DiMuro, Mike | Rays | Safe | Out | Overturned |
| 5-Apr | 34 | HP | West, Joe | Dodgers | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 5-Apr | 33 | 2B | Hoye, James | Mets | Out | Safe | Overturned |
| 5-Apr | 32 | HP | DeMuth, Dana | Yankees | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 4-Apr | 31 | 1B | DeMuth, Dana | Yankees | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 4-Apr | 30 | 1B | Wendelstedt, Hunter | Rays | Trap | Catch | Overturned |
| 4-Apr | 29 | 1B | DeMuth, Dana | Yankees | Out | Safe | Overturned |
| 4-Apr | 28 | 1B | Barrett, Ted | Royals | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 4-Apr | 27 | 2B | Foster, Marty | Giants | Safe | Out | Overturned |
| 4-Apr | 26 | 2B | Danley, Kerwin | Tigers | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 4-Apr | 25 | 3B | Hudson, Marvin | Braves | In Play | Dead Ball | Overturned |
| 3-Apr | 24 | 2B | Gonzalez, Manny | Mariners | HR | HR | Upheld |
| 3-Apr | 23 | HP | Barber, Sean | Athletics | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 3-Apr | 22 | HP | Knight, Brian | Yankees | Ball 3 | Ball 3 | Upheld |
| 3-Apr | 21 | 1B | Ripperger, Mark | Reds | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 3-Apr | 20 | 2B | Wendelstedt, Hunter | Rockies | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 3-Apr | 19 | 1B | Layne, Jerry | Rockies | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 2-Apr | 18 | 3B | Hirschbeck, John | Cubs | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 2-Apr | 17 | 2B | Morales, Gabe | Indians | Out | Safe | Overturned |
| 2-Apr | 16 | HP | Davidson, Bob | Pirates | Foul | Foul | Upheld |
| 2-Apr | 15 | 2B | Tumpane, John | Cubs | Out | Safe | Overturned |
| 2-Apr | 14 | 2B | Layne, Jerry | Marlins | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 2-Apr | 13 | HP | Wegner, Mark | Athletics | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 2-Apr | 12 | 3B | Scott, Dale | Twins | Catch | No Catch | Overturned |
| 2-Apr | 11 | 1B | Conroy, Chris | Tigers | Safe | Out | Overturned |
| 2-Apr | 10 | 1B | Conroy, Chris | Tigers | Out | Safe | Overturned |
| 1-Apr | 9 | 1B | Guccione, Chris | Giants | Safe | Safe | Upheld |
| 1-Apr | 8 | 1B | Wolf, Jim | Blue Jays | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 1-Apr | 7 | 1B | Wolf, Jim | Blue Jays | No HR | No HR | Upheld |
| 1-Apr | 6 | 2B | Blaser, Cory | Rangers | Safe | Out | Overturned |
| 31-Mar | 5 | HP | Winters, Mike | Indians | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 31-Mar | 4 | 1B | Fagan, Clint | Nationals | Out | Out | Upheld |
| 31-Mar | 3 | 1B | Davidson, Bob | Pirates | Safe | Out | Overturned |
| 31-Mar | 2 | 1B | Gibson, Greg | Braves | Safe | Out | Overturned |
| 31-Mar | 1 | 1B | Davidson, Bob | Cubs | Out | Out | Upheld |
A few notes raised in the wake of the system's first week:
1.
With such a subjective distinction: should throws pulling middle infielders off the bag be considered unreviewable under the "neighborhood play" category?
Review #15: review granted, runner safe.
2.
Why isn't Rule 7.13 being properly applied to catchers?
Review #32: catcher not blocking the plate.
Note: "Unless the catcher is in possession of the ball, the catcher cannot block the pathway of the runner as he is attempting to score."
3.
Why are incorrect calls still being made?
Review #26: runner safe, ball not lost on transfer.
. . .
All statistics courtesy of Close Call Sports.
Joshua Mastracci is a contributor to Beyond the Box Score. You can follow him on Twitter at @joshuamastracci.