clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

A Graphic Look at the Window to Win: Cincinnati Reds


Just in time for prospect season, we take a look at the idea of "windows" and a team's prime time to win. Inspired by what seems to be a once every three years rebuild for the Oakland Athletics, is there going to be a time where all their premier prospects hit and they'll have the best chance to win? Here we present the pleasures of trying to maximize production during one's service time.

24th in the series (we're almost through all the teams!), we look at the Cincinnati Reds. We have a team ranked 21st overall by John Sickels with 1 A-rated prospect and 5 B-rated prospects. Of course, they would have been ranked higher before trading away a number of their top prospects in return for P Mat Latos. They rank 18th in Kevin Goldstein rankings and 19th in Keith Law's 2012 organizational rankings. Law believes that this was a potential top-10 system before the trade. For those of you who were skeptics about the trade, Goldstein brought up a good point in his rankings:

Using prospects to acquire talent is one of the primary reasons for having prospects in the first place.

After acquiring Latos and closer Ryan Madson this offseason, are the Reds window finally opening in the NL Central?

Letting C Ramon Hernandez walk this offseason opened up the postion for the eventual promotion of top prospect C Devin Mesoraco. Mesoraco will temporaily share time with C Ryan Hanigan, but it's clear the future is with Mesoraco at starting catcher. Using WARP, PECOTA projects Hanigan/Mesoraco combo to excel. Lets compare to what Hernandez would have done:

2012 Projections (based off of Baseball Prospectus PECOTA)
2.6 WARP, 279 PA
2.1 WARP, 250 PA
WARP, 313 PA

Seems like quite the upgrade. Here's what the Reds roster projects to be in 2012:

*New acquisition, Current roster info from MLB Depth Charts

Starting Lineup
1 2B Brandon Phillips
2 SS Zack Cozart
3 1B Joey Votto
4 3B Scott Rolen
5 RF Jay Bruce
6 LF Chris Heisey
7 CF Drew Stubbs
8 C Ryan Hanigan

C Devin Mesoraco
3B Juan Francisco
IF Miguel Cairo
IF Wilson Valdez
OF Ryan Ludwick

Starting Rotation
1 RHP Johnny Cueto
2 RHP Mat Latos
3 RHP Bronson Arroyo
4 RHP Mike Leake
5 RHP Homer Bailey

CL RHP Ryan Madson
SU LHP Sean Marshall
SU RHP Nick Masset
MID LHP Bill Bray
MID RHP Jose Arredondo
MID RHP Logan Ondrusek
LR RHP Sam LeCure

The upgrade of Latos in the rotation should be a projected 3.7 WARP. Finishing with only 79 wins was a bit of a disspointment, but surely with the upgrades, they should improve on that easily. The oh so early CAIRO projected standings from last month had the Reds at 87 wins, one win away from the second wild card berth.

Jonah Keri agrees on the optimism in the end of his Reds season preview by saying:

The Reds vie for their first World Series title in 22 years. No, really. You can go to war with Cueto and Latos at the top of your rotation, one of the best lefty-righty bullpen combos in the game in Marshall and Madson, Votto scaring the bejesus out of even the most dominant pitchers, and a supporting cast that gets better-than-expected results out of Bruce, Stubbs, and the catchers, with Phillips and Rolen holding their own.

With the changes this offseason, if the Reds can live up the to 87 win projection, it appears that the window for them to win is opening. Now all they need to do is make sure they can figure out if they're able to re-sign both 2B Brandon Phillips and 1B Joey Votto to extensions or find viable solutions.

See the previous graphics in this series: Mariners | Athletics | Astros | Cubs | Pirates | Royals | Twins | Indians | Padres | Diamondbacks | Rays | Jays | Braves | Nationals | Mets | Marlins | Phillies | Red Sox | Orioles | Yankees | White Sox | Tigers | Cardinals

Check out or Follow @cobradave