clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

2011 MLB Playoff NLDS Preview: Cardinals vs. Phillies

NLDS Preview: Cardinals vs. Phillies | Diamondbacks vs. Brewers
click to enlarge

Saturday at 5:07pm EST, the Cardinals and Phillies square off for game one of their NLDS series.

Like the Rays, St. Louis found themselves improbably making the playoffs on the very last day of the season, courtesy of a Phillies sweep of the Braves. Now, the Cardinals face the Phillies and their historic group of front-line starting pitchers in a short series.

At first glance, this series looks like a total mismatch. While the Cardinals show a little more pop in their offense, the Phillies run prevention is just incredible.

The Phillies trio of Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee, and Cole Hamels have been dominant whether they are at home or on the road. All three are likely to garner Cy Young votes, as well they should.

However, the series gets interesting if you look at the Phils' performance against the Cardinals, in particular at Busch Stadium.

In nine games against the Birds, the Phillies gave up 3.81 runs per nine innings, their third worst against any team in the league. When playing at Busch Stadium, their ERA increased to 4.04. Now, the Phillies have not played in St. Louis since June, but considering that Busch Stadium is not exactly friendly to hitters it's worth thinking about.

Additionally, the Cardinals offense did a pretty good job at Citizens Bank Park this year, posting an OPS+ of 120. Moreover, they generally hit Philadelphia as well as you're going to, posting an OPS+ of 128 against them which was good for third in all of baseball.

That being said, the Cardinals draw a lot of offensive strength from their power, but the Phillies staff does a great job of preventing the long ball (second-lowest HR/FB against in the NL, and that's without the benefit of San Francisco's schedule or home park). Moreover, Matt Holliday only managed three home runs during the month of September, due in part to a sprained hand. Albert Pujols and Lance Berkman can certainly provide pop, but the Cardinals' chances would look a whole lot better with a solid-swinging Holliday in the line-up.

While these numbers suggest the match-up isn't necessarily a cake walk for the Phillies, it's hard to imagine losing three out of five when you can roll out Halladay, Lee, and Hamels for all five starts.

My prediction: Cardinals run out of gas, Philadelphia cruises to the NLCS with a series sweep.


Graphic Guide: League average is scaled to 100. Scores higher than 100 indicate performance better than league average, less than 100 indicates performance worse than league average regardless of the statistic. For example, if a team has a FIP of 110% on the graph their actual FIP is 10% better than league average.

Statistics have not been park adjusted, but are adjusted for each team's respective league.


RS/G: Runs Scored per Game

wOBA: Weighted On-base Average

OBP: On-base Percentage

SLG: Slugging

BABIP: Batting Average on Balls in Play

LD%: Line-drive Percentage

HR/FB: Home run to Fly Ball Ratio


RA/G: Runs Against per Game

FIP: Fielding Independent Pitching

tERA: True Runs Allowed

SIERA: Skill-Interactive Earned Run Average (FanGraphs' version)

BABIP: Batting Average on Balls in Play

K/BB: Strikeouts to Walk Ratio

HR/FB: Home run to Fly Ball Ratio