As with the Lincecum selection we had this one pegged two months ago.
| Real | Projected |
| Lee | Lee |
| Halladay | Halladay |
| K-Rod | Matsuzaka |
| Matszuaka | Lester |
| Rivera | Santana |
I didn't include relievers in the original, but I'm pleased that the starting pitchers order was correct. Whether or not you think K-Rod is more deserving than the others is up for debate, although frankly I would've rather seen Rivera in third if we had to have a top three closer.