Officially. The voters got the right guy, but the MLB subheading is horrible: "Lead the National League in winning percentage..." Sigh. If you recall, Bill James formula projected Lincecum to win almost two months ago, here's the results v. projections.
| Real | Projected |
| Lincecum | Lincecum |
| Webb | Webb |
| Santana | Sabathia |
| Lidge | Dempster |
| Sabathia | Santana |
| Dempster | Billingsley |
Two of the top three isn't bad, after that things fall apart a bit. I'll post one of these for the American League results as well, which come out on Thursday.