clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Barry Zito Profile

New, comments

Nothing has changed since my Barry Zito profile was published over at Baseball Prospectus, so I refer you to that for my view of Zito. One thing that I should say though, San Francisco definitely has a park built for Zito, although it is not as suited for him as Oakland's was due to having less foul ground. It should help reign his flyballs in about the same though, which will be important in keeping Zito somewhat effective. Of course, moving to the National League, which is more of a Three True Outcomes -- homeruns, walks, and strikeouts -- league is not going to help Zito, who gives up homeruns, walks a ton of batters and doesn't strike out many guys.

Giving any pitcher seven years is ludicrous though, even someone who has been as durable as Zito. If his arm falls apart after the heavy workload in Oakland, just like Mulder and Hudson's seem to have, the Giants will be even worse off than expected. If he does stay healthy, they have a #3 starter for the next few years, and I guess that's something. The money doesn't bother me so much, even though he's being overpaid for his services. I'm not sure where the idea of Zito as ace really came from, since he did not even deserve the one Cy Young award that he was selected for.

Here's the link to the profile; you decide if he's worth seven years, $126 million:

He gives up a fair number of line drives, and those flyball rates are higher than the groundball ones. Toss in the number of home runs he allows while remembering that he'll probably get worse before he markedly improves, and it may be wise to hold off on showering Zito with scads o'cash. If the Mets get him--and if there's actually something positive that will happen to him back under Rick Peterson's tutelage--then he should be worth the contract. Additionally, from 2004-2006 Shea's BABIP was .291, while league average was .301. If San Diego signs him, Petco (.288 BABIP) may be even better able to do for Zito what the Coliseum did. Beyond that pair of suitors, it's probably best that teams like the Rangers and the Yankees avoid Zito, and better for Zito if he only treats their bids as leverage.