Travis d'Arnaud is off to the worst start I have ever seen

Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

As a thirty year old Mets fan, I can't remember a player, particularly a highly touted prospect, starting their career as poorly as Travis d'Arnaud at the plate. Let's see what the numbers say.

As a baseball fan, I like to evaluate things based on my lifetime. There is some honor to saying, that is the greatest player I have ever seen, or, that is the worst performance I can ever remember. Having turned thirty this past year, I consider the previous twenty or so years of my life as baseball devoted. I may have been playing with an oversized glove, swinging a tee-ball bat, or flipping through baseball cards before then, but it wasn't until I was in the third or fourth grade when things really started to click, when baseball made sense, mind you, long before the other necessities of growing up, such as homework or girls, ever did.

So when I look at Travis d'Arnaud, the prized prospect the Mets acquired by trading R.A. Dickey, and think about how his lack of performance at the plate stacks up against the myriad poor performers that my favorite baseball team, the Mets, have put before me, I am considering a historical reference of about twenty years, dating back to 1994. And I can say, with some certainty, that d'Arnaud has been the least exciting, worst hitting, prospect I have ever seen.

Travis d'Arnaud has an OPS+ of 57 through 70 games in the big leagues. He is only 25, having appeared in a mere 257 plate appearances. Obviously, both traditionalists and sabermetricians alike would scream for sample size. 'Let's see how he looks over 1,000 plate appearances', we could say. While that is fair, it doesn't overlook the fact that in those first 70 games, he has been downright awful. The worst. And if we want to consider how often a player starts their career as slow as d'Arnaud and still turns into a good hitter, we have a starting point by his age and limited plate appearances.

Before we consider how d'Arnaud compares historically across baseball, let's keep our focus on the Mets. Why don't I remember a player starting as poorly as d'Arnaud in my lifetime? Well, because literally no Mets player with at least 250 plate appearances by their age-25 season has had as bad of a start at the plate since 1994.

Rk Player BA OBP SLG OPS+ PA From To Age
1 Travis d'Arnaud 0.189 0.277 0.269 57 257 2013 2014 24-25
2 Rey Ordonez 0.257 0.289 0.303 60 530 1996 1996 25-25
3 Kelly Stinnett 0.234 0.332 0.344 80 398 1994 1995 24-25
4 Ruben Tejada 0.255 0.325 0.317 81 1546 2010 2014 20-24
5 Jordany Valdespin 0.219 0.271 0.380 81 350 2012 2013 24-25
6 Josh Thole 0.261 0.331 0.333 85 1026 2009 2012 22-25
7 Kirk Nieuwenhuis 0.236 0.305 0.366 87 422 2012 2013 24-25
8 Alex Ochoa 0.273 0.320 0.386 88 605 1995 1997 23-25
9 Juan Lagares 0.255 0.296 0.372 90 593 2013 2014 24-25
10 Lastings Milledge 0.257 0.326 0.414 91 391 2006 2007 21-22

Even Rey Ordonez, who hit like a pitcher, found more slugging success early than d'Arnaud.

David Wright had an OPS+ of 139 by his age-25 season; Mike Piazza's was 140. It seems that the cream rises to the top fairly quickly, and looking at the names on the list above - Kelly Stinnett, Ruben Tejada, Josh Thole - with the hopeful exception of Juan Lagares, it seems the bad stay bad, too.

So how about for players across baseball, and not only Mets? Using OPS+, since that accounts for league average, neutralizing the offensive bonanza that was the late nineties, d'Arnaud is off to the 34th worst start since 1994 for a 25-year-old player in their first 250 trips to the plate. In the past 20 years, over 700 players have made at least 250 plate appearances by the time they turned 25, and only 33 were less difficult to get out than d'Arnaud.

Is there any hope? Let's rethink the sample size we are considering - only 250 plate appearances. Surely, there are instances when players started off poorly but found their groove, once they got more at-bats.

Rather than compare d'Arnaud to the best of the best—in other words, concerning ourselves with whether he will turn into a Mike Piazza—let's refine our criteria to search for instances where players have started as poorly as d'Arnaud, and maybe never turned into Hall of Famers, but at least, for one season, got their act together enough to turn into All-Stars. Since 1994, of the players with at least 250 plate appearances through their age-25 season, only three eventually made an All-Star team while starting their career with an OPS+ of 57 or lower. Since 1994, there have been 215 players who made at least 250 PAs by the age of 25 and eventually became an all-star. Again, only three did so with an OPS+ as low as d'Arnaud's.

Rk Player BA OBP SLG OPS+ PA From To Age
1 Dan Wilson 0.216 0.244 0.312 42 303 1994 1994 25-25
2 Brandon Inge 0.194 0.247 0.298 49 553 2001 2002 24-25
3 Damion Easley 0.215 0.288 0.314 57 760 1994 1995 24-25
4 Jack Wilson 0.246 0.292 0.330 61 1626 2001 2003 23-25
5 Mark Grudzielanek 0.245 0.300 0.316 61 293 1995 1995 25-25
6 Michael Bourn 0.237 0.299 0.313 62 658 2006 2008 23-25
7 Jose Offerman 0.210 0.314 0.288 63 289 1994 1994 25-25
8 Johnny Estrada 0.228 0.273 0.359 64 324 2001 2001 25-25
9 Jason Bartlett 0.233 0.308 0.322 67 266 2004 2005 24-25
10 Cesar Izturis 0.261 0.295 0.338 69 2407 2001 2005 21-25

Travis d'Arnaud is a catcher; we shouldn't overlook the fact that he has done completely the opposite of what the scouting reports suggested he would do. As bad as he has been swinging the bat, he has been as good framing pitches for the Mets' staff. There is definite value to a catcher who is defensively sound, but that is not what d'Arnaud was brought to New York to do; he would have to be a defensive genius to justify his meager offense.

After batting .180 on the season, with three home runs and nine RBIs, having played, essentially, everyday, the Mets were forced to send d'Arnaud back to the minors (where he has found some recent success). Having watched him play most of those days, I can tell you that he is one of the least exciting prospects I have ever seen. It turns out the numbers back that up.

. . .

All statistics courtesy of FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference.

Jeffrey Bellone is a writer and editor at Beyond The Box Score and can also be found writing about the Mets at Amazin' Avenue and Mets Merized Online. He writes about New York sports at Over the Whitestone. You can follow and interact with him on Twitter @OverWhitestone.

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Beyond the Box Score

You must be a member of Beyond the Box Score to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Beyond the Box Score. You should read them.

Join Beyond the Box Score

You must be a member of Beyond the Box Score to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Beyond the Box Score. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9351_tracker