Re-Defining "Good at Everything" (thanks to community feedback)

Just yesterday I wrote a post that attempted to define which players were "Good at Everything". My original goal of the post was lost a bit with the title I chose. The plan was to find all players that were positive in every Rally WAR component. I did that. But I made it sound like it was a definitive list of who was "Good at Everything". It really wasn't.

Luckily, Beyond the Box Score has some fantastic commenters and they helped me out. So, I've got a new list of guys. This list should come closer to capturing guys who were "Good at everything".

Again, here's the original criteria I used:

  • Batting runs, Baserunning runs, Total Zone runs, and Positional Adjustment runs are all greater than 0.
  • GIDP runs, Reach on Error runs, Infield DP runs, Outfield Arm runs, and Catcher runs are all greater than or equal to 0 (this is because some older players only have a 0 for their career because there isn't any data available for these categories).

Simply running this search yielded 49 players in the history of the game.

[...] batting runs is a pretty broad skill. We can break that up into individual skills. So, I went with the two OPS components—on base percentage (for patience) and slugging percentage (for power). I cut out any players below league average for their careers in either of these categories.

In this second version, I added these criteria:

  • Instead of requiring both Total Zone and Position to be above zero, I required the combination of both to be above zero. However, I excluded players with negative Total Zone who still managed to get a positive TZ+Pos.
  • I ignored the "Reached on Error" category.
  • I cut off the list at a 25 WAR minimum. You gotta put in some time to be good at everything. This seemed to be a good cutoff, right after Hall of Famers Freddie Lindstrom and George Wright.

The new list features 40 players:

Name PlApp Bat ROE BSrun DP TZ IFDP OFarm catcher Pos WAR Pos+TZ
Barry Bonds 12511 1213 -6 45 6 153 0 36 0 -129 171.8 24
Honus Wagner 11518 699 0 45 0 66 19 0 0 104 134.5 170
Tris Speaker 11679 845 0 14 0 92 0 0 0 -72 133.0 20
Nap Lajoie 10239 581 0 2 0 62 21 0 0 6 104.2 68
George Davis 9976 380 0 28 0 143 3 0 0 87 90.7 230
Joe DiMaggio 7657 579 0 30 0 49 0 0 0 -19 83.6 30
Charlie Gehringer 10096 391 0 38 0 30 4 0 0 74 80.9 104
Bill Dahlen 10235 188 0 25 0 139 0 0 0 140 75.9 279
Frankie Frisch 9871 195 0 63 0 115 25 0 0 73 74.8 188
Lou Whitaker 9787 209 -10 33 17 70 7 0 0 51 69.7 121
Alan Trammell 9175 124 12 21 19 59 17 0 0 118 66.9 177
Frank Baker 6507 285 0 7 0 35 0 0 0 52 63.7 87
Jackie Robinson 5689 276 7 39 1 51 28 2 0 20 63.2 71
Sal Bando 8166 208 17 11 5 28 8 0 0 38 60.6 66
Jack Glasscock 7531 116 0 8 0 149 0 0 0 108 58.7 257
Bid McPhee 9359 150 0 37 0 154 0 0 0 42 57.9 196
Billy Herman 8470 167 0 12 0 37 18 0 0 65 55.6 102
Stan Hack 8391 240 0 24 0 2 0 0 0 15 54.8 17
Carlos Beltran 6790 178 11 52 14 67 0 4 0 18 54.7 85
Buck Ewing 5764 231 0 43 0 16 0 0 58 35 51.8 51
Tommy Leach 8811 114 0 43 0 67 0 0 0 5 50.9 72
Ichiro Suzuki 6555 148 3 45 40 93 0 34 0 -52 50.7 41
Max Carey 10480 97 0 106 0 86 0 0 0 -84 50.6 2
Frank Chance 4988 252 0 33 0 47 0 0 0 -25 49.5 22
John McGraw 4894 337 0 24 0 3 0 0 0 34 49.3 37
Hughie Jennings 5538 225 0 20 0 60 0 0 0 51 48.0 111
Heinie Groh 6853 157 0 3 0 35 0 0 0 44 46.4 79
Gil McDougald 5271 94 4 6 2 83 16 0 0 42 40.0 125
Eric Chavez 5242 108 -5 5 4 61 2 0 0 12 36.2 73
Dan McGann 5881 159 0 14 0 37 0 0 0 -34 36.2 3
Don Buford 5266 111 -1 10 12 58 0 4 0 -10 35.5 48
Fred Dunlap 4264 147 0 3 0 80 0 0 0 19 34.7 99
Harlond Clift 6841 141 0 5 0 3 0 0 0 18 34.7 21
Chase Utley 3777 140 1 20 13 49 4 0 0 15 34.5 64
Ross Barnes 2506 252 0 15 0 57 0 0 0 15 33.1 72
Joe Mauer 2959 162 -6 6 2 0 0 0 41 31 33.1 31
Dom DiMaggio 6421 111 0 25 0 37 0 0 0 -11 31.9 26
Robby Thompson 5117 43 18 18 5 18 18 0 0 28 31.0 46
Freddie Lindstrom 5958 79 0 14 0 21 0 0 0 10 29.2 31
George Wright 2942 128 0 16 0 75 0 0 0 35 28.5 110

 

New faces on the list:

  • Barry Bonds: gets on there despite a huge positional adjustment hit thanks to amazing total zone numbers.
  • Tris Speaker: his total zone was also enough to overcome the positional adjustment.
  • Joe DiMaggio: had only a minor positional adjustment hit that was easily overcome.
  • Lou Whitaker: so glad to see him on here—was only left off because of ROE.
  • Ichiro: easily overcomes his positional hit with awesome range. He's another active player for the list.
  • Max Carey: HOFer's range beats out positional adjustment by two runs.
  • Frank Chance: slick-fielding first basemen CAN make this list!
  • Eric Chavez: betchya didn't see THAT coming—only missed the first time because of ROE.
  • Dan McGann: turn of the century slick-fielding first bagger makes that two.
  • Don Buford: call him "slightly above average at everything"—makes up for a minor positional hit.
  • Joe Mauer: only ROE held him back the first time.
  • Dom DiMaggio: when one DiMaggio isn't enough.

I'm more comfortable with this list. Are you?

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Beyond the Box Score

You must be a member of Beyond the Box Score to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Beyond the Box Score. You should read them.

Join Beyond the Box Score

You must be a member of Beyond the Box Score to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Beyond the Box Score. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9351_tracker