Book Review - "Satchel - The Life and Times of an American Legend" by Larry Tye (Including an Interview with the Author)
Random House has been kind enough to provide a free copy of Satchel to one BtB reader. All you have to do is make a comment on your favorite Negro League player. In a week, I will randomly choose a name and Random House will send that reader a free copy of the book
I've received several requests to review books since going BtB. Between my own writing and two toddlers to contain, I barely have time to sleep, yet alone read a book. When I was contacted to do a review of "Satchel", I jumped at the opportunity, though. I've always been interested in the Negro Leagues, mainly because Kansas City has embraced their history, given the Negro League Baseball Museum in Kansas City and the Monarch's Pennant and Championship flag flying at Kaufman Stadium, and I was happy to do a review of the book.
The book was outstanding and I would recommend it to anyone interested in Satchel Paige, Negro League history or what baseball was like when it was being integrated in the middle part of the last century. I don't want to just rehash what is in the book so I have decided to highlight some areas I found interesting and include an interview wtih the book's author, Larry Tye.
The most interesting story I enjoyed was when Satchel about had to give up baseball 20 years earlier than he did. In 1939, he lost his ability to throw with any speed due to an unknown injury, which was possibly a torn rotator cuff. Frank "Jewbaby" Floyd, the Monarchs trainer, helped him regain his velocity by soaking his arm in cold and then hot water. Then Frank alternated cold and hot wraps and applied an ointment called "Yellow Juice". Finally, he limited Satchel to just a few innings of pitching. All of the preceding measures are remedies used today for rotator cuff tears, except that "Yellow Juice". I have been looking for a video of Satchel throwing before the injury for Kyle Brodie of Driveline Mechanics for him to examine to determine the possible injury, but I not had any luck in finding the video.
There were several other stories from the book which were pretty memorable. One story was when Satchel began calling Buck O'Neil the name Nancy after Buck helped Satchel hide one of his girlfriends from his wife. Another is the circumstances around Jackie Robinson being the first black player in the majors. It seemed like Stachel was going to be the first player several times and when it was Jackie, Satchel and several other players were bitter. A sad one involved when Satchel could no longer play ball. He still had to make a living and did it by being the guest speaker at events. From these events, he would take back home as much food and stuff as he could carry. Once had a bag break and his half eaten meal from room service the night before fell out.
Currently, accurate numbers for Negro League play don't exist, but Satchel is almost guaranteed to hold many Negro League Records once the final numbers are released. Here are several major league records and firsts that Satchel currently holds.
-
Oldest rookie at age 42
-
First black man to pitch in the World Series
-
First "vintage" Negro League player elected to Hall of Fame
-
Only pitcher in the Hall of Fame with a losing record
Besides these facts and stories on Satchel, the book had some great facts on black baseball and here are a few facts that I never knew.
-
Moses Fleetwood Walker was the first black player to play for a professional baseball team. He played 42 games with Toledo in 1884. In 1898 baseball became segregated until Jackie Robinson joined the Dodgers.
-
Negro Leagues never kept track of a pitcher's ERA, instead it was total runs.
-
The 1935 Pittsburgh Crawfords had 5 future Hall of Famers on it, Josh Gibson, Oscar Charleston, Cool Papa Bell, Judy Johnson and Satchel Paige, and is considered the best black team ever. Satchel considered the best team ever put together, black or white.
-
Latin America attracted many black players in the 1930's and 1940's because of the lack of racial prejudice. Many of the players stayed in Latin America.
A couple of facts from the book peaked my personal interest. In 1950, Satchel joined a group of black all stars that called themselves the Kansas City Royals. I am going to try to find out if this is where the current Kansas City Royals got their name or if it was just a coincidence. In 1960, Satchel threw for the Salina Kansas Bluejays. My wife is from Salina and we were married there. I can't find any information on the web about his stint with the Salina team, but when I head back home, I will be sure to check it out.
I did find one aspect of the book a little annoying and is that it was written as if the reader had little knowledge of baseball. Here are 3 examples of the book defining terms that many baseball fans would already know
-
"..like balks, an illegal pick off move where all runners advance on base."
-
".... shot at a perfect game, where all twenty-seven batters are retired in succession."
-
"..was two for six, for an average of .333"
These should not keep you from reading the book, but they were just a little annoying to me.
----------
After finishing the book, I contacted Larry Tye and he gladly answered the following questions for me on the experience:
How's life been after publishing the book? Looks like you have had a pretty busy schedule.
Life since the release of Satchel has been even more fun than life while I was reporting and writing it. Imagine having your publisher send you around the country, doing talks to people who love baseball, love the Negro Leagues and love Satchel Paige. Imagine dozens of ballclubs inviting in you in to talk to thousands of fans, with some team owners giving away copies of your books and others selling them.
It has been busy, and been a blast.
Have you found/obtained any new information on Satchel since the book was published?
Yes, I have heard fun stories I hadn't heard before from Satchel's fans, his teammates and foes, and his daughters. All had been helpful before, but everywhere I go I hear new tales of his mythical accomplishments from people who swear they were there, and of his touching sensitivity as a dad.
What part of researching the book what the most difficult?
Coming up with numbers from the Negro Leagues isn't easy. Reporters from black papers covered games sporadically, and from white papers rarely. The league couldn't afford to keep statistics. Scholars have dug up some numbers, but not complete or consistent ones. I pieced all that together for Satchel and, more important, talked to more than 200 old Negro Leaguers and Major Leaguers who played with or against him.
You can judge from my book whether I offer a complete enough portrait.
What part of researching the book did you enjoy the most?
The interviews with old ballplayers.
What part of researching the book did you enjoy the least?
The footnotes and bibliography. I felt these were essential, given how few books on black baseball include them and how important it is to offer this guidepost to future researchers. But putting all that together is time-consuming and not fun.
Looking back, is there anything you left out that you wished you would not have?
No. I did leave out a lot, but feel that most readers, no matter how passionate they are about a topic, don't want a book that is longer than 300 pages. So it is an author's responsibility to include only her/his best material.
Looking back, is there anything you printed that you wished you would not have?
Nothing that I can think of.
Any future projects we can expect from you?
Yes, I am working on a biography of Superman for Random House. It was partly an outgrowth of Satchel, and my interest in how America embraces the heroes it does. There was no longer-lasting hero over the last 100 years than the Man of Steel.
Is there any other statement or information you have to say?
I think that is more than anyone wants to hear from me. If they want more, they should have a look at my website and blog at www.larrytye.com.
------------
I definitely recommend this book to anyone interested in the subject matter. Larry did a great job of putting together Satchel's life, from being born in Mobile Alabama to his death in Kansas City. If you read the book, I hope you enjoy it as much as I did.
0 recs |
18 comments
|
Comments
Moses Fleetwood Walker
Recent research indicates that William Edward White, might have been the first black player, not Walker. Walker was a much more important historical figure, though.
My favorite Negro leaguer would probably be Ray Dandridge; supposedly would make Brooks Robinson look like an amateur over at third base.
by aCone419 on Aug 26, 2009 10:02 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Cool Papa Bell
A Lou Brock type player – aggressive baserunner and great switch-hitter. Stole 175 bases in a 200 game season once. Great fielder who hit over .400 several seasons. Probably a 3000 hit man in the big leagues.
by yummy on Aug 26, 2009 11:54 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Satchel Paige
Is my favorite. Being a major league quality pitcher into his 50’s is simply unprecedented. I’m not talking about that one game in 1965, but his record with the AAA Miami Marlins at ages 49-51. Most of his teammates pitched in the big leagues at some point, so the wonders of Baseball-reference allows one to estimate what the MLE factors would be. Satchel was probably the best pitcher on those teams or close to it, I have no doubt he still had major league stuff at that point.
If my comment is picked for the free book, please give it to someone else, already have it and highly recommend.
The HK-47 hitting droid is the finest line drive machine ever built
by RallyMonkey5 on Aug 26, 2009 1:18 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Hilton Smith
He might’ve been just as good as Satch (though we’ll never know), just didn’t have the aura that Paige has.
Aaron King is still my homeboy... iffy mechanics and all
McFAQ for all you newcomers out there.
GET THAT VORP AND WHIP SH!T OUTTA HERE!!!
by baetown415 on Aug 26, 2009 2:47 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Josh Gibson
I’ve always wished he could have played MLB so we could have more accurate stats to compare him with Ruth. It always impressed me that, although he was referred to as the “black Babe Ruth”, some people that watched both he and Ruth play called Ruth the “white Josh Gibson.” It would have been awesome to see him hit.
"Baseball has been good to me since I quit trying to play it." - Whitey Herzog
by Bring Back Tommy Herr! on Aug 26, 2009 3:12 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Buck O'Neil
If he’s good enough for Poz then he’s good enough for me
by metserock44 on Aug 26, 2009 4:16 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Willard Brown
Great power hitter in the Negro Leagues. By the time he got a chance in the majors it was mostly for show and he didn’t really have a whole lot left, though he did smash an inside-the-park home run against Hal Newhouser.
by pmoney55 on Aug 26, 2009 4:17 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
So tough to choose just one
I’d have to say Satchel Paige because I’ve always loved the anecdotes and stories attached to him, but I also love Cool Papa Bell, Gibson, Buck O’Neil, and Buck Leonard.
"I never threw an illegal pitch. The trouble is, once in a while I toss one that ain't never been seen by this generation." - Satchel Paige
by Steve Slowinski on Aug 26, 2009 7:20 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
"Cool Papa Bell was so fast he could get out of bed, turn out the lights across the room, and be back in bed under the covers before the lights went out."
Heard that when I was a kid (a Josh Gibson quote, I believe) and have been a Bell fan ever since.
by JonBBT on Aug 26, 2009 7:25 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
It was Satchel....
JonBBT—I like that one myself, but it was one of Satchel Paige’s witticisms.
There’s another related story: a number of years after Satchel made his observation about Cool Papa Bell’s extraordinary footspeed, the two men were roommates when the team was on the road. In one of the rooming houses where they stayed, Cool Papa discovered that their accommodations came with a malfunctioning light switch. It seems there was a minor short-circuit that produced a delay of several seconds between the time the switch was thrown and the time the light went out.
That evening, when he and Paige were about to retire for the night, Bell turned down his bedclothes and then ambled over to the wall switch. “Satchel,” he said, "you’ve told an awful lot of people that I could do this…."
At which point, Cool Papa flipped the switch, sprinted over to his bed, leaped in, and had the covers pulled all the way up to his chin before the light went out
“…And now you finally see that I really can!” and he started to laugh.
For once, the joke was on Satchel.
The story sounds apocryphal, but Buck O’Neill said it was true and that’s good enough for me.
by dlreed52 on Aug 27, 2009 3:22 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'd have to say Josh Gibson
and although not a player I always found Gus Greenlee to be a fascinating character (owner of the Crawfords)
I made most of my life decisions at a Foghat concert... I stand by them.
by Chester J Lampwick on Aug 26, 2009 9:34 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Satchel in Salina
Take a look at this for info on Satch in Salina:
http://seamheads.com/blog/2008/11/27/satchel-paige-1960/
KJOK
by KJOK on Aug 27, 2009 1:14 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
With the link all I get is Not Found
I wil look around for a bit
Jeff Zimmerman - Protecting the world from RBI's and Wins from my mom's guest house.
by Jeff Zimmerman (TucsonRoyal) on Aug 27, 2009 9:45 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Looks like the Blog Section is down/not working for some reason
Jeff Zimmerman - Protecting the world from RBI's and Wins from my mom's guest house.
by Jeff Zimmerman (TucsonRoyal) on Aug 27, 2009 10:07 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Cannonball Dick Redding
The problem with being a lesser light is that if you have the misfortune to shine at the wrong place or in the wrong time, it doesn’t really matter that you’re a great big ball of fire: hardly anyone sees you, hardly anyone remembers you clearly, and eventually you wink out of sight and into obscurity. That was true of many fine pitchers in the Negro Leagues—stylish southpaws Charlie Beverly and Luis Tiant, Sr., submariners Will Jackman and Webster McDonald, and mixmasters Chet Brewer and Sug Cornelius. Any one of these men, given an opportunity, could have had an outstanding career in the majors.
But the pitcher I’d really have loved to have seen was a flamethrower who hailed from Atlanta, Georgia: Cannonball Dick Redding. His speed was legendary, comparable—some said superior to—that of Walter Johnson, and like Johnson in his younger days, Redding’s repertoire consisted of fastballs, fastballs, and more fastballs.
But just because you knew what was coming didn’t mean you knew when: Redding frequently used a no-windup delivery in an age when pitchers double- and triple-pumped and pinwheeled their throwing arms before actually delivering the ball. And when he did wind up, “Cannonball” employed a hesitation pitch trickier and more exacting than the one Satchel Paige would dazzle batters with in later generations. In its execution, it might remind the modern fan of Fat Freddie Fitzsimmons or of Luis Tiant the Younger. Redding would swivel around on his right leg, turning until his left shoulder was pointing at the shortstop hole and his broad back faced the batter.
Then he would pause. Two seconds. Five seconds. Maybe even longer…. And then he’d wheel around and—whoosh!—in came another heater.
For most pitchers, that kind of delay and the stressful mechanics of balancing on one leg might cause them to be out of sync and to lose a little off their stuff. However, because the Cannonball’s game was simply to step and throw, the hesitation worked beautifully—especially since he had no compunction whatsoever about shaving batters with his high hard one. Imagine facing a flamethrower who turns his back to you for what seems an interminable interval and then whistles one under your chin!
Often compared to Walter Johnson because of his outstanding speed, he’s also comparable to Mordecai “Three-Finger” Brown because like the Cubs right-hander who was Christy Mathewson’s personal nemesis, Redding battled and frequently bested Smokey Joe Williams, the greatest Negro League pitcher of his era. The two men were fierce rivals and had a rather contentious relationship outside the foul lines as well.
Pitching in tandem for the Lincoln Giants in 1911, however, they may have been the greatest one-two mound combination in baseball history, a pair of strikeout aces the likes of which hadn’t been seen before and rarely since. Competing against all comers, Williams would frequently fan twenty or more batters in a nine-inning game—many of the teams were of the bush-league variety, sure, but keep in mind that this was the same pitcher who whiffed 20 New York Giants while pitching a no-hitter (though losing 1-0 on an error) in 1917 and 27 Kansas City Monarchs in winning a 12-inning one-hitter in 1930. Redding, playing second fiddle to Williams’ concertmaster, compiled a 43-12 mark, pitching several no-hitters (including one against the Cuban Stars) and fanning 25 of the 27 batters he faced in another game. Not bad for a second banana.
Cannonball Dick Redding would continue his mound mastery until 1924, his career interrupted only by a two-year stint in the military during World War I. In 1925, his great speed finally gone, he shucked his toe plate after logging a lackluster 3-4 record and managed the Brooklyn Royal Giants for a half-dozen years.
That this great moundsman had to toil in relative obscurity because of racial prejudice was a terrible injustice; that he was overlooked by the Special Committee to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in 2006 was an awful mistake.
by dlreed52 on Aug 27, 2009 2:33 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
"Only pitcher in the Hall of Fame with a losing record"
Satchel Paige was the first pitcher to enter the Hall of Fame with a losing record, but he was later joined by Rollie Fingers who won 114 games but lost 118 over 17 major league seasons….
Andre Dawson has a bruised knee and is listed as day-to-day. Aren't we all?
--Vin Scully
by dlreed52 on Aug 27, 2009 5:03 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I honestly don't know much about the Negro Leagues.
But I can start by purchasing this book. Thanks for the review.
by Wilder. on Aug 27, 2009 2:15 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 












BtB on Facebook
















