Dave Cameron Declares the NL West Race Over
"Congratulations to the Los Angeles Dodgers for clinching the first playoff spot of the 2009 season.
"Things could go wrong. The whole team might get the swine flu. Short of that, however, this division race is over."
Over at FanGraphs, Cameron is going ahead and closing the book on one of the pennant races. He has good points, of course. The Dodgers are 20-8, 8.5 up already, unbeatable at home (so far litterally), have the best run differential in baseball (+48) and the rest of their division doesn't look too good.
But, through the first 28 games last year, the Diamondbacks were 20-8. Their run differential was almost a full win better at +56, and they were in first place of a division that was surprising people (by being worse than expected) while young players were seemingly coming in to their zones. They were only up 5 1/2 games to the Dodgers' 8 1/2 this year, but the point still remains: it's early.
The situations aren't exactly the same, and the Dodgers are absolutely in the drivers' seat of the division and it will probably be a small surprise if they don't win. But recent history makes it pretty clear teams can absolutely fall down after seeming to be dominant in May. Unexpected young players can crash, other teams can get big boosts with players being added to the roster, the ups and downs of a long baseball season can happen, and a division can surprise you by being better or worse than you assumed it would be. And while a month isn't a completely dismissable sample-size, it's also not completely acceptable; if people thought the Diamondbacks would be able to compete this year, it's not necessarily time to jump completely off the bandwagon. I'm not saying the Dodgers aren't the favorites by a pretty sizable margin so far, I'm just saying a team in their own division is proof it's a little early to be declaring things over, and it doesn't take something as drastic as swine flu to see to that.
almost 3 years ago
philkid3
11 comments
1 recs |
Comments
BPro doesn't have their playoff odds report up.
Coolstandings.com, which has some issues, mostly that they don’t use any pre-season projections, just the previous year’s data and current season record, has the Dodgers at an 80% chance to win the division. Then again, Toronto’s at 46% and Texas is 50% more likely than Seattle to win the division, with the same record.
http://www.coolstandings.com/baseball_standings.asp?i=1
Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.
BP does have their postseason odds up.
no ELO, though.
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/statistics/sortable/
White Sox Minor League Updates: http://twitter.com/SouthSidelarry
Thanks.
Using the PECOTA-adjusted version, the Dodgers sit at 85% to take the division. And the Blue Jays at 5%, which shows why projection adjusted projections (uh, that makes sense, right?) are the way to go. Of course, I think PECOTA and CHONE were too bearish on the Jays, but 5% is better than 45% from coolstandings.
http://www.baseballprospectus.com/statistics/ps_oddspec.php
Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.
I would imagine it would take something big for the Dodgers to lose this lead
…something like Manny Ramirez being banned for 50 games.
it's a good thing the dodgers resisted the temptation to trade juan pierre.
White Sox Minor League Updates: http://twitter.com/SouthSidelarry
sorry. i thought the thick sarcasm of posting something like that on this site would come through loud and clear.
White Sox Minor League Updates: http://twitter.com/SouthSidelarry
Ok, Manny...
Dude’s a, say, 5 WAR player. 1/3 of that is 1.7 WAR. Juan Pierre, for all the crap he takes, is better than replacement level. So over 50 games, we’ll say the Dodgers are losing an expected 1.5 WAR from Manny. Important, sure. Killer? No way.
Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.


















