Beyond the Box Score: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: World Soccer Digest for Soccer Fans!

Graph of the Day: Piazza vs. Pudge

War_-_piazza_vs_pudge_3636_image001_medium

Two catchers, two very different ways of providing value.

Piazza stakes claim to the best hitting catcher ever, but he was generally below average behind the plate.

In the early part of his career, Pudge saw most of his value come from his glove (and more importantly, his arm) while his offense lagged behind.

I didn't realize how quickly Piazza's value dropped, nor that Pudge was so valuable so recently.

WAR data from Baseball Projections.com.  All data relative to average, except RAR. 

0 recs  |  Comment 31 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Great graph, Dan. Piazza’s sharp decline in win total surprised me a little, too. Pudge’s still-usefulness doesn’t surprise me as much because I was looking at some projections for him recently and he’s still in the area of 1.5-2 wins as a player.

by xanthan on Mar 9, 2009 11:14 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Graphs like these make me think two things:

1) Could you imagine how filthy good Piazza could’ve been if he had any idea what he was doing behind the plate?

and

2) His decline starts in earnest in 2003 – the same year as the anonymous steroid testing commenced. You know, if you’re into conspiracy theories.

by MatthewA on Mar 9, 2009 1:27 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

COINCIDENCE?

Space.

It's a problem we face.

So we never go anywhere.

We just stay in one place.

by hazel on Mar 9, 2009 2:57 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Murry Chass is that you?

King of the bling come to lay down the evidence//Not George Bush, L-Millz be da president

by Sam Page on Mar 9, 2009 3:17 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Anyone who watched the Mets during the Piazza years

Could have told you about the decline.

It went from pitchers being able to hold people on to looking forward to seeing how many SBs the opponents would have, with the baseline assumption of 2/game.

But, of course, his arm strength was not at all related to steroids.

by klhoughton on Mar 9, 2009 4:09 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

So

Do we value peak years, consistancy or longevity more? You can make a case for all of these guys, really except for Piazza.

vivaelbeñsheets

by vivaelpujols on Mar 9, 2009 5:51 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I'd say

One 6WAR season is worth much more than two 3WAR seasons, much scarcer…so I’d go with Bench probably

by viktor06 on Mar 9, 2009 6:00 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Actually

According to the Pennants Added concept, a high peak isn’t as valuable as a consistent above average performance. So one 6 WAR is actually worth less than two 3 WAR seasons if the ultimate goal is their random team making the playoffs. In that case, you might have to go with Rodgriguez who has never been below replacement level and has usually been an above average player.

vivaelbeñsheets

by vivaelpujols on Mar 9, 2009 6:20 PM EDT up reply actions   1 recs

What is your basis for choosing that?

If you were a manager, would you rather have a player put up one 6 WAR season, than a 0 WAR season, or have a player have consecutive 3 WAR seasons. As I linked above, the latter is more conducive to your team making the playoffs.

vivaelbeñsheets

by vivaelpujols on Mar 10, 2009 4:50 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

scarcity

its much easier to find a 3WAR player…

by viktor06 on Mar 10, 2009 5:20 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

It's more impressive. Not saying it's any more valuable.

3 WAR seasons are WAY more common than 6 WAR seasons. When I think of great ballplayers, I want them to have done things that are rare and impressive.

Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.

by Sky Kalkman on Mar 10, 2009 5:33 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Ok

vivaelbeñsheets

by vivaelpujols on Mar 10, 2009 9:33 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

That's interesting stuff...

I had never run across it before.

Now, I can’t make any quantitative judgement without the formulas in front of me, but it seems as though the difference in PA between two 4 WAR years and a single 8 WAR year is pretty tiny, perhaps even so small as to be irrelevant. That being said, I wouldn’t have thought there would be that much equality between the two. It does seem kind of intuitive though – that pesky Law of Diminishing Returns seems to kick in everywhere else in life, so why not baseball?

by BraveBronco0121 on Mar 10, 2009 10:17 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Easy

1. Copy the text from baseballprojection.com
2. Paste into notepad
3. Paste that into excel
4. Sort as desired
5. Graph it
6. Post and enjoy.

by Harry Pavlidis on Mar 10, 2009 10:04 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

firefox + excel = notepad first

Dunno why, but that’s the way it goes for me.

by Harry Pavlidis on Mar 10, 2009 3:47 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I use the Web Query from Excel

I’d love it if Sean included the full season totals when a player splits time between two teams though – saves me from having to add them “manually”

by Dan Turkenkopf on Mar 10, 2009 5:14 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Maybe?

You don’t know who you’re dealing with, bucko. Pudge is one of the five greatest baseball players ever with Ruth, Bonds, Nolan and Hamilton. None of those guys were catchers.

Don’t maybe me.

(But do continue to post your awesome graphs.)

by philkid3 on Mar 9, 2009 10:55 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

We use numbers and stuff.
Community Guidelines
Why be a member?
Start posting on Beyond the Box Score »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Leopold_butter_scotch_southpark_small
Using the TVC
Small
Determining Batted Ball Rates using Pitch Type and Location
Small
a new xBABIP calculator
Img587561916661595
Top 15 high school MLB draft prospects
Small
PZR-based Win Values 2001-2006
Small
The "30 parks on a budget" challenge
Sunflower_small
World Series Simulation, Game #6
Small
JT20 Dynasty League
E52205a2_small
New Look
Sth70021_small
Exploring Hit f/x, Albeit Badly

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

Primer on BaseRuns
Cool Baseball Infographics
ESPN's Jerry Crasnick on defensive metrics
I’m also a follower, since Brian Bannister’s on our team, of sabermetric st...
Top Ten Baseball-Reference.com's Sponsorships
Primer on Linear Weights
JC Bradbury on "Hot Stove Myths"
Everyone Should Learn to Throw a Cutter
Criminals of WAR
Ten statisticians you should know about

+ New FanShot All FanShots >

BtB on Twitter

Main Feed: @BtBScore

Tommy B: @tommy_bennett
Sky: @BtB_Sky
Dan: @dturkenk
Harry: @harrypav
Jinaz: @jinazreds
Jack: @jh_moore
Erik: @Erik_Manning
Tommy R: @trancel
Justin: @justinbopp

Subscribe to BtB via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

BtB Goes Social


Managers

Nando_small R.J. Anderson

Limes_125_small Sky Kalkman

E52205a2_small Tommy Bennett

Editors

Face_small Harry Pavlidis

Rawlings_baseball_bigger_small Dan Turkenkopf

770insig_small Jeff Zimmerman (TucsonRoyal)

Aviles_small Justin Bopp

Authors

Banny_small erik

Raysring1_small Tommy Rancel

Jinaz-reds-avatar_small JinAZ

Jmlogo_small Jack Moore

1753738656_110919ebe9_o_small vivaelpujols

1_small Graham

Baseball_small Mike Rogers

Redcap_small SFiercex4

Small Patrick Clark

Walter_album_small Walter Fulbright