Saber-Friendly Blogging 101: Best Position Players In Franchise History
BtB reader and Rangers' fan philkid3 has a cool post up at LSB about the best players in Rangers history (well, since 1955, at least). He included pitchers via a different method, which you can tackle if interested, but here's how to come up with a neat list of the best position players for your own team. As always, feel free to throw links to your own post in the comments of this one.
- Jot down 25 or so names that you think might be in the top 10. Don't skimp on slick fielders, 2B/SS/CA, or people born before you. For some help, generate a list of the top OPS+ in franchise history using B-Ref's PI tool.
- Look up those 25ish players in Sean Smith's historical WAR database. Why use this source? Because Sean accounts for basically all significant aspects of a player's context-neutral on-field production: hitting, baserunning, GIDPs, range, position, turning DPs, catcher defense, etc.
- Add up their WAR for all seasons as a member of your team. These players did the most to help your team win games since 1955.
- Add up the WAR of their best five consecutive seasons for your team and divide by five. This is one way find the average production of a player's peak.
- Add up the WAR of their best three season for your team and divide by three. This is another way to find the average production of a player at his peak.
- Rank the players you looked up by any or all of the three metrics outline in points 3 to 5 above. Maybe think about only presenting the top ten and provide some interesting words about each, such as where they derived most of their value (offense, defense, baserunning, whatever -- Sean lists it all at his site.)
- Don't do any of the above, and wait for Sean to create leader boards for his WAR data. ETA: anywhere from one day to one year.
Update: Brew Crew Ball is taking this position by position, which is even cooler.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Cardinals
might not be a complete list but: Career as a Cardinal / 5yr average / Best 3 years
Pujols: 67.9 / 9.04 / 10.03
Edmonds: 45.5 / 7.26 / 7.7
Ken Boyer: 52.1 / 5.96 / 6.7
Ozzie Smith: 61.1 / 6.2 / 6.6
Stan Musial: 32.6* / 4.7* / 6.667*
K. Hernandez: 35 / 5.43 / 6.533
Ted Simmons: 46.6 / 4.98 / 6.06
Rolen: 29 / 4.52 / 6.36
Lankford: 39.1 / 5.08 / 5.86
Brock: 41.3 / 4.52 / 5.26
- Stan Musial’s career started in 1941, he was just that good
Stan Musial was arguably the most consistent hitter in history
1815 hits at home, 1815 hits on the road. I think that stat is amazing.
Considering that the stat only starts in 1955
Stan was 34 in 1955 so the stats only include one season of OPS+ of 170+
From 1941-1954 Stan had 6 seasons of 170+ OPS+ and averaged OPS+ of 170.3
It wouldn't be hard to figure out his overall WAR
You would just take his wOBA from each – the league average wOBA/1.2 * plate appearances. For defense you could just use TucsonRoyal’s true UZR prediction with his recorded TZR data.
vivaelbeñsheets
FWIW
The Senators began play in 1961, and they’ve only been the Rangers since 1972 (and we only included Rangers). So the 1955 cut off is no issue.
Thanks for the suggestion
It was interesting to go through the best players of the team – there were a couple of surprises. I went by position and overall for the O’s.
C: Chris Hoiles
1B: Eddie Murray
2B: Bobby Grich
3B: Brooks Robinson
SS: Cal Ripken Jr.
LF: Brady Anderson
CF: Paul Blair
RF: Frank Robinson
P: Jim Palmer
#10: Paul Blair (32.3 wins above replacement)
#9: Brady Anderson (33.4)
#8: Bobby Grich (33.1)
#7: Frank Robinson (33.1)
#6: Boog Powell (38.1)
#5: Mike Mussina (50)
#4: Eddie Murray (57.1)
#3: Jim Palmer (64.5)
#2: Brooks Robinson (70.4)
#1: Cal Ripken Jr. (91.2)

by 
















