Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Chauncey Billups Injures Achilles Tendon

Quick UZR/PMR Comparison

Now that FanGraphs is publishing MGL's UZR, I wanted to see how the 2008 results compared to David Pinto's PMR (which I converted to runs here).

I ran a quick correlation for each position containing the players qualified according to PMR - those who were on the field for at least 1000 balls in play.

 

Position Correlation
Pitcher NA
Catcher NA
First Baseman 0.71501645
Second Baseman 0.58129407
Third Baseman 0.62672569
Shortstop 0.68798239
Left Fielder 0.74839581
Center Fielder 0.52849967
Right Fielder 0.80255003

There were definitely some issues in center field, and to a lesser extent 2B.  The two systems had a high level of agreement in the corner OF positions. 

The 10 biggest disagreements were:

 

Player Position PMR UZR Diff
Akinori Iwamura 2B -17.25 0.6 17.85
Pedro Feliz 3B -10.19 7.2 17.39
Troy Glaus 3B -13.85 3.3 17.15
Edgar Renteria SS -16.14 0.9 17.04
Jose Reyes SS -18.21 -1.5 16.71
Brad Hawpe RF -21.64 -37.2 15.56
Melvin Mora 3B -17.81 -3 14.81
Torii Hunter CF 4.81 -9.8 14.61
Dan Uggla 2B 14.85 0.3 14.55
Bobby Abreu RF -11.45 -25.2 13.75

Both PMR and UZR were calculated using the Baseball Info Solutions (BIS) data set this season.  I wonder if David or MGL might be able to give some ideas as to where the differences might come from.

 

Comment 4 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

When I saw Abreu at -25 runs by combined ZR, I couldn't wrap my ahead around how that was even possible.

But now we see -37 runs from Hawpe. Really? That’s like -45 plays, or one every 3.5 games. Given that a corner outfielder might see, what, three batted balls per game, that’s like 1/10 opportunities that Hawpe screws up that an average fielder doesn’t. And considering, what, at least 2/3 of those opportunities are “routine”…

Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.

by Sky Kalkman on Dec 8, 2008 10:43 AM EST reply actions  

UZR and PMR

I don’t remember all of DP’s methodology or if he has changed it much since its inception, but I vaguely recall there being quite a few differences. Any time you have two different engines processing the same data, you are bound to have some large differences, especially in small (say, one year) samples.

Sky, above, that does not mean that Hawpe is screwing up 1/10 of his opps, or some such thing. A large number, plus or minus, is extremely likely to be a fluke. If you see someone with -37, it likely means that he is a bad fielder (maybe -18 if that -37 is in 150 games or so) and that the other -19 runs are “flukey.” “Flukey” could be hard balls to catch that “appeared” easy according to the data, 5 or 6 balls (or 10 or whatever) that 50% of all fielders would have gotten to, but Hawpe happened to have just missed, balls that an adjacent fielder would have or should have gotten to but didn’t (in UZR when any player catches a ball, no other players get docked, and when no one catches a ball every player whose position EVER caught a similar ball gets docked some amount). Etc.

When you see a number for a fielder, NEVER think in terms of that number and “how it could be.” Always think in terms of the proper regressed number and how THAT could be. That goes for all sample metrics – offensive, defensive, etc.

by mgl on Dec 10, 2008 3:18 AM EST reply actions  

I'm with you, MGL, don't worry.

Wondering how -37 “could be” could be useful just to show how unlikely it actually is “to be”. You know, in case someone actually thinks Hawpe was THAT bad.

Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.

by Sky Kalkman on Dec 10, 2008 5:20 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

We use numbers and stuff.
Community Guidelines
Why be a member?

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Free Agent Compensation
Img_0001_small
Value of Various Plate Approaches
Strike_three2_small
Effect of Foul Area on Strikeouts: AL 1954-68: Erratum
Small
Baseball on a stick
Small
Player Evaluating Statistic
Baseball_small
Rays Outfield: Cheap but Extremely Productive
Small
A new xBABIP
Small
Jack Morris "pitching to the score"
Strike_three2_small
Foul Area and Differences in SO: AL vs NL
Baseball_small
Is there a Kuroda and Oswalt Alternative?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Follow us on Facebook!

Follow us on Twitter!

SaberGraphics

MLB Daily Dish

Get the latest MLB Trade Rumors, Transactions, and News at MLB Daily Dish!


Managing Editor:

Jbopp-kc_small Justin Bopp

Columnists:

Adam_small adarowski

Dme_small Satchel Price

Closeup4_small J-Doug

Carlosicon_small Julian Levine

Billy_and_daddy_4th_of_july_small Bill Petti

Featuring:

Dayton_small Jeff Zimmerman

12475953_small Jacob Peterson

Picture-6_small Chris St. John

Btbpro_small Dave Gershman

229331_10150183361996591_674441590_6760167_6637860_n3_small Lewie Pollis

Img_3830_small David Fung