To me, this makes the Jeter Gold Gloves look understandable. He was -40 in plus/minus this year. In the numbers Sky presented to us, he was worth -16 runs in the field. I've never heard of a reputation for him, I see no evidence anywhere for liking him.
How did he win? How? I know the Gold Glove is a joke, but there still has to be some reasoning.
Also: Albert Pujols gets robbed. Again. People really don't like him. And Brandon Phillips did to Chase Utley what Utley's partner did to Tulowitzki last year, so I'll call that Karma.
Finally: Can anyone give me evidence that Maddux really deserved this and didn't just win, again, on reputation?