Beyond the Box Score: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Steve McNair Dead - Former NFL QB Shot and Killed


SBN Awards: Manager of the Year Preface

This week's featured SBN Award is the Manager of the Year. Frankly I don't have a ton to say about it. Sure, we can theorize that Joe Maddon is a calming influence on his troops, however outside of lineup and bullpen usage we really don't know how much value he possesses. Ned Yost and Dave Sveum may differ in their teaching philosophies but it's impossible to truly judge them.

In all honesty the MOY is almost always given to the "surprise" team's manager, or the manager of the best team. That's not to say the award is entirely useless, but does anyone truly believe that Dusty Baker (three-time winner) is a better manager than Davey Johnson? There's only so much influence a manager can have over his team's performances, and I can't help but go back to Joe Maddon for numerous examples. To believe Maddon suddenly learn this off-season how to make his team win 31 more games seems silly, especially when you consider his personnel upgrades, but some people may say he kept the team focused, not me, but some.

My question is: how do you judge managers?

 

0 recs | Comment 13 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

More from Beyond the Box Score

Comments

Display:

Who was stupid less often than anyone else?

That’s really what it comes down to. I’m of the opinion that there are two or three managers who influence their team in a positive way, two or three managers who influence their team in a negative way, and a whole bunch of managers that don’t really have all that much of an effect.

The issue is that the positive effect is pretty much impossible to measure. What’s the WPA of a good manager? Who the hell knows? Is it even possible to know? Unless you watch a team 20-30+ times in a given year, it’s hard to even get a feel for a manager’s tendencies.

I know that doesn’t really come close to answering the question, but that’s the thing; I don’t even know if you can answer the question.

J.K.L.

by acblue on Oct 6, 2008 2:58 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

it's like that not-so-old adage:

Good managers get too much credit, and bad managers get too much of the blame.

"Lefty relievers are like the different Mountain Dew flavors. New ones keep appearing, and people are willing to buy, but in the end most of them suck." - Gallagher's Watermelons

by scatterbrian on Oct 6, 2008 8:09 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Most wins over PECOTA?

I dunno. Seems as good as anything.

by philkid3 on Oct 7, 2008 3:49 AM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

maybe not wins over PECOTA

but you could use wins over third order wins as a starting point…..that would mean Scioscia (16) and Cooper (10.2)…..Scioscia’s a solid choice, and Cooper’s OK I guess….but with the Phillies having the third-highest differential (5.2), I’d go with Manual instead.

"Lefty relievers are like the different Mountain Dew flavors. New ones keep appearing, and people are willing to buy, but in the end most of them suck." - Gallagher's Watermelons

by scatterbrian on Oct 8, 2008 1:56 AM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

how can you tell that stuff isn't just dumb luck?

or something like baserunning or outfield throwing arm which aren’t traditionally measured? (those wouldn’t matter in Pythag, though.)

Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.

by Sky Kalkman on Oct 8, 2008 9:45 AM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

you can't

we’re not sure what it is about teams who exceed or fall short of their Pythag record….but I tend to think that, after luck, it has something to do with in-game management: use of the bench, deployment of the bullpen, calling for steals/hit and run, etc.

"Lefty relievers are like the different Mountain Dew flavors. New ones keep appearing, and people are willing to buy, but in the end most of them suck." - Gallagher's Watermelons

by scatterbrian on Oct 8, 2008 12:44 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I think some managers can really make a difference with individual players.

Getting their heads in the right place, etc. But there’s no way we can really know when that happens.

We can, however, judge then based on personnel moves, in-game strategy, etc. Most managers are hurting their teams in these regards, and the better ones probably are worth a few games over the bad ones. Personally, I’d vote for Manny Acta as Manager of the Year, since he’s outwardly admitted to holding to intelligent, sabermetric principles. Will Acta get any support from the BBWAA? No way.

Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.

by Sky Kalkman on Oct 7, 2008 12:19 PM EDT reply reply actions actions   0 recs

That's not fair... you can't vote for a guy just based on what he SAYS he does...

That’s like voting Brian Bannister for Cy Young because he tries to get ahead in the count early.

Your 2008 Athletics: It's Nothing Personal.

by PaulThomas on Oct 7, 2008 7:11 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

we have plenty of proof that Bannister doesn't do what he's trying to do, though

is there proof that Acta makes poor decisions? (I honestly don’t know as I really don’t follow the Nationals much.)

Beyond the Boxscore // Calling BJ Upton lazy is lazy.

by Sky Kalkman on Oct 7, 2008 7:39 PM EDT to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

We use numbers and stuff.
Community Guidelines
Start posting on Beyond the Box Score »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

P1_iannetta_small
Matt Herges: The reason we look at peripherals
Small
SLG and Speed
Small
Interleague Attendance Nonsense
Limes_125_small
A Note About Becoming a BtB Author: Contributing to the Community Helps
Small
Is Adrian Beltre underrated...?
Limes_125_small
How Do You Like the New Daily Link Roundup Posts?
Stlouiscardinals_small
Depth Charts Help
Zorilla_small
How Do You Measure a Pitching Coach?
Limes_125_small
Looking For SQL & Tech Geek Help For Collaborative Projects
Small
When do MLBers get paid...?

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recent FanShots

There's your human element.  Why, when the technology is readily available, are humans still calling balls and strikes?
Fire Jim Leyland: Fu-Te Ni Follow Up; Concern Over Big Three?
Rany Gets Banned By the Royals
Contract Retrospective: Vernon Wells' 7-year, $126 Million Contract
The Rockets are innovative
Flip Flop Fly Ball
Yanks Considered Trading Rivera For Wells In '95: MLB Rumors - MLBTradeRumors.com
Bullpen Usuage Charts for Last 5 days
MiLB Game of the Week
Drive Mechanics Looks at Chris Perez's Mechanics and Pitch F/X numbers

Post_icon New FanShot All FanShots Carrot-mini

Most Commented

Subscribe to BtB via Email

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

BtB Goes Social

BtB on Facebook

BtB_Sky on Twitter


Managers

Mos-def-the-ecstatic_small R.J. Anderson

Limes_125_small Sky Kalkman

Editors

Rawlings_baseball_bigger_small Dan Turkenkopf

Face_small Harry Pavlidis

770insig_small Jeff Zimmerman (TucsonRoyal)

Rickstache_small erik

Authors

Jinaz-reds-avatar_small JinAZ

Hms_surprise_small Graham

Wisc19cropped2_small jhmoore

Raysring1_small Tommy Rancel

E52205a2_small tbsmkdn

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports